Is Your Contract Maritime? Fifth Circuit’s In re Whitney Oil & Gas Decision Affirms Operating A Vessel For Transportation Is Not Maritime
Is Your Contract Maritime? Fifth Circuit’s In re Whitney Oil & Gas Decision Affirms Operating A Vessel For Transportation Is Not Maritime
- Authors Ambrose Stearns, Thomas Frederick
Building on Genesis Energy, L.P. v. Danos, L.L.C. and In re Aries Marine Corp., the U.S. Fifth Circuit again narrowed what is considered a maritime contract. In In re Whitney Oil & Gas, L.L.C., No. 25-30560 (5th Cir. Oct. 21, 2026), the court held that a Master Service Agreement (MSA) for offshore production operators was not maritime, even though the contractor’s own employees operated the vessels used to travel to the platforms. As a result, Louisiana law applied and the Louisiana Oilfield Indemnity Act (LOIA) voided the MSA’s indemnity provision.[1]
Background and Holding
Quality Process Services (QPS) supplied production operators to Whitney Oil and Gas under a 2016 MSA. The operators traveled by vessel to Whitney’s platforms, then disembarked to read gauges, check pipes, and monitor wells. After Hurricane Ida, a QPS employee operating a Whitney vessel allided with a well jacket, injuring a Whitney employee. Once the injury claims settled, only QPS’s indemnity claim against Whitney remained.
Doiron Test
The question was whether the MSA was a maritime contract or not which the court analyzed under the Doiron test.[2] The Doiron test provides that a contract is maritime if it (1) provides services that facilitate drilling or oil-and-gas production on navigable waters, and (2) provides, or the parties expect, that a vessel will play a substantial role in the completion of the contract.[3] The parties expectations play a central role in this analysis.
As is frequently the case in these situations, the only dispute was Doiron’s second prong: whether the parties expected that a vessel would play a substantial role in completing the contract. The court held that the MSA was not maritime because the parties did not have the expectation that a vessel would play a substantial role in the completion of the contract, because for the purposes of the “substantial use of a vessel” test, transportation to a from fixed platforms does not satisfy the substantial use test.
Operating A Vessel For Transportation Does Not Constitute Maritime Work
QPS argued that the substantial use test should have been met here since QPS’s own employees were operating the vessel, and their operation of the vessel was expected and anticipated by the parties when they executed the MSA. QPS argued that this set them apart from being “mere passengers”. The court reasoned, however, that the work that was being contemplated in the contract was service to fixed platforms was “work that is not maritime in nature” and the vessel use contemplated (transporting workers to the platform) was merely incidental or ancillary to that fixed platform and non-maritime work.
Key Holding:
- Use of a vessel to transport workers to a fixed platform does not help to satisfy the Doiron This case adds that there is no exception when the contractor’s employees drive the vessel. “Providing a ride to work falls short of the ‘substantial role’ that Doiron requires.”
Actual Use of a Vessel Only Matters If the Expectations of the Parties in the Contract Are Unclear
QPS also argued that even if the MSA did not contemplate the use of a vessel, the work was modified during Hurricane Ida by the parties’ verbal work orders. QPS argued that the work changes conducted under unusual circumstances should modify the Doiron analysis. The court held, however, that actual vessel use should only be contemplated when the terms of the contract are unclear.
Key Holding:
- Actual vessel use during the Ida shut-in was irrelevant because the parties’ expectations were clear; actual use matters only when the contract and expectations are unclear.
Key Developments
Whitney clarifies that the “substantial use of a vessel” test from Doiron excludes any vessel use for transportation or housing, even if the parties themselves are operating the vessel.
How to Analyze Whether Your Contract Is Maritime
- Confirm the first Doiron prong. Does the contract provide services to facilitate oil and gas drilling or production on navigable waters?
- Read the contract’s scope of work. Does it call for substantial work to be performed from a vessel? Disregard maritime choice-of-law clauses, statute references, and marine insurance requirements.
- Exclude non-qualifying vessel uses. When calculating “substantial use of a vessel”, exclude vessel use that consists of transportation of crew or equipment (even if the work being contracted for is operation of the vessel), housing, meals, supply delivery, and other ancillary functions.[4]
- Ask where the work happens. If the work being performed and equipment being used are on the platform rather than on the vessel, the contract is likely non-maritime (thus indemnity may be prohibited under LOIA). A vessel serving as the work platform (as in Crescent Energy or Barrios) points toward maritime.
- Confirm a shared expectation. Both contracting parties, not third parties, must have expected the vessel to play a substantial role when they entered the contract.[5]
- Consider actual use only if still unclear. Evidence of how vessels were actually used is relevant only when the contract and expectations remain unclear, and it is not a separate test.
Key Takeaways
Offshore service contracts centered on platform work will rarely qualify as maritime, and maritime-sounding boilerplate will not change that. Parties to MSAs governed by Louisiana law through OCSLA should review their risk allocation and insurance programs rather than assume indemnity obligations will be enforced. A general maritime law choice-of-law clause, references to the Jones Act and the Limitation of Liability Act, and marine insurance requirements do not make a contract maritime.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Ambrose Stearns and Thomas Frederick are members of Kean Miller’s Offshore Energy & Marine group, based in the firm’s Lafayette office. They defend offshore service providers, operators, insurers and other energy and maritime clients in complex litigation in state and federal courts. They also regularly advise on contract review and formation, contractual defense and indemnity, limitation of liability actions, and the risk-allocation questions at the center of offshore and oilfield operations.
[1] Last session, LOIA was amended for the first time since its enactment in 1981. Among other changes, the amendment seeks to clarify LOIA’s scope and creates a new statutory procedure allowing operators to obtain additional insured coverage under their contractors’ policies. For a detailed discussion of the amendment and its expected impact, see our blog: Louisiana Oilfield Indemnity Act’s Additions Under HB 941.
[2] In re Larry Doiron, Inc., 879 F.3d 568, 571 (5th Cir. 2018).
[3] Our team provided a brief overview of the Doiron test when the Fifth Circuit adopted it in 2018. Before Doiron, courts applied a complicated six-factor test to determine whether a contract was maritime. As our article noted, “Lawyers are notorious for mucking up the works and over complicating seemingly straightforward issues,” and multi-factor analyses are no exception. The Doiron test was, as the article aptly put it, “a breath of fresh air.”
[4] For a deep dive into what uses are “substantial,” see our discussion in Is Your Contract Maritime? Genesis v. Danos Adds Clarity to the Maritime Contract Discussion.
[5] The Fifth Circuit recently addressed this aspect of Doiron in In re Aries Marine. Although the crew spent considerable time aboard a vessel while working offshore, including eating and sleeping there, the court held that the vessel’s role was not substantial enough to make the contract maritime. The parties expected the work to take place only on a fixed platform. If you would like a more detailed analysis of the Fifth Circuit’s recent application of the Doiron framework, see our article The U.S. Fifth Circuit Adds Another Layer to the Maritime Contract Analysis in In Re Aries Marine Corp.